Tuesday, August 4, 2015

The Misunderstanding of Chip Kelly

Much has been made of Philadelphia Eagles head coach Chip Kelly’s penchant for parting ways with talented football players in order to create his kind of culture in the locker room.  DeSean Jackson was the first and many followed this past offseason as Kelly gained total control of personnel over Howie Roseman.  The trade of running back LeSean McCoy, the release of all-pro guard Evan Mathis and most recently the trade of cornerback Brandon Boykin raised eyebrows across the National Football League.

                                                                                Associated Press
Wide receiver Riley Cooper is still with the team two years after uttering a racial slur in public.  As a result, the public has questioned Kelly’s ability to handle egos.  McCoy and Boykin both made comments following their departures from the team that insinuated Kelly does not work well with the black players on his team.


In today’s world, it’s easy for someone who has made decisions as bold as Kelly’s to be misunderstood.  That is what has happened here as the third-year coach decided to put the team through a roster makeover in the offseason and the motives behind his moves were blown out of proportion. 

Chip Kelly’s job is to win football games for the Eagles.  Who cares if he does not relate well with certain players on the team? That’s not what he’s getting paid to do.  Granted, culture has certainly driven some of his moves but if he feels that creating a certain culture is necessary to win then what’s the big deal?  While his decisions have people questioning if Kelly is a racist, there are football reasons behind many of his moves as well.

Let’s start with the trade of McCoy to the Buffalo Bills for inside linebacker Kiko Alonso.  After taking heat for not getting anything for Jackson in 2014, Kelly moved McCoy and his hefty cap hit to Buffalo for a 24-year old inside linebacker who appears to be fully healthy after missing all of 2014 with a torn anterior cruciate ligament.  Alonso had an impressive rookie season in 2013 and with two years left on his rookie contract serves as a cheap option for production on defense. 

To replace McCoy, Kelly signed former Dallas Cowboy DeMarco Murray.  Murray’s downhill, straight ahead running style is different than McCoy’s who tended to dance and look for big plays at times when nothing was there. In Kelly’s fast-paced offense, a back like Murray who’s going to take what’s there and gain yards as often as possible is very important to keep the chains moving.  So with the McCoy trade, Kelly got a young and cheap inside linebacker who figures to be a key contributor on defense in Alonso and replaced McCoy with a better scheme fit in Murray.

Trading Brandon Boykin was a classic case of getting something for someone who isn’t in your long-term plans.  Boykin is in line for a new contract following the 2015 season.  There’s a strong possibility that contract would not be another one with the Eagles had the nickel corner remained on the roster in 2015.  The Eagles brought in an influx of defensive backs as Kelly continued to remake the team in the spring.  They signed Byron Maxwell and Walter Thurmond.  E.J. Biggers and Jaylen Watkins will compete for spots on the roster in camp. They drafted Eric Rowe, JaCorey Shepherd and Randall Evans. Nolan Carroll is returning for his second season with the Eagles with a chance to start opposite Byron Maxwell as the team’s other cornerback.  Boykin was hopeful to be given a chance to move outside and start but with the way the Eagles approached the offseason it’s clear they wanted to move in a different direction and so they gave Boykin a chance to start outside on a Pittsburgh Steelers team in desperate need of cornerbacks. 

The Eagles got a 5th round draft pick back for Boykin but it could be a 4th round selection if Boykin plays 60% of Pittsburgh’s defensive snaps in 2015.  So it seems like a win-win.  Boykin should get a chance to play outside in Pittsburgh and if all goes well the Eagles will get a 4th-round draft pick back for him which is decent value in return for someone who you weren’t planning on keeping around beyond this upcoming season anyway.


At the end of the day, Chip Kelly is a football coach that is trying to win games.  Say what you want about any preferential treatment that may or may not exist, this looks like the best roster Kelly has to work with in his three years with the Eagles and he was the one who assembled it.  Winning solves everything and if everything goes according to planned, no one will care about how well Chip Kelly relates with his players.

No comments:

Post a Comment